Hey, Blaine from Dtcpod here. And today we've got two amazing AI tools for you guys to check out. So AI is obviously eating the world, and these two by HubSpot where you're really going to love. So the first one's, called Content Assistant, basically helps you create amazing content, which matters more today than ever. Everyone's creating content, so you got to stand out. With HubSpot's AI powered Content Assistant, you can brainstorm, create, and share content of Flash, all inside a super easy to use CRM.
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
DTC POD
Meghana Dhar
Speaker
Blaine Bolus
Speaker
Meghana Dhar
Speaker
Ramon Berrios
03:39 ebay: OG e-commerce, disruptive, evolving inventory. 05:42 PayPal, creators, sellers: eBay's unique community culture.
✨ Magic Chat
Don't have time for the full episode?
Ask anything about this conversation — get answers in seconds, sourced from the transcript.
Try asking
Featured moments
Highlights
“And I'd love to go a little back. Let's go back and start with ebay maybe, and then we can kind of talk through some of the other experience.”
“And, you know, I really think ebay is like the OG e commerce website... they started this whole idea of a marketplace... people don't give them enough credit, like they're OGS, they're ballers. And I think they disrupted the Internet in their time.”
“Yeah, it's interesting because back then, community or creators weren't a thing, right? It was black and white, supply and demand.”
“ebay did a really good job of cultivating their community and listening to them and honestly, they showed a lot of care to their creators. I don't think the same can be said about Instagram et cetera, right now...”
“'One of the power dynamics I think they had is that the supply can be the demand and the demand can be the supply. Meaning like, the buyer can become a seller finds out, oh, I can sell my stuff here.'”
Timeline
How it unfolded
Read along
Full transcript
So think things like brainstorming, blog ideas, blog outlines, drafting copy on any topic from marketing trends to media kits or writing value, props for your landing pages, prospecting, emails, and more. The second one is Chatspot, which is basically a conversational bot that sits on top of your HubSpot
CRM. So it's going to automate all the manual tasks inside of HubSpot, help you engage more customers, close more deals, and scale a little bit faster. So if you want to find out more about how to use AI to grow your business, check out Hubspot.com Artificial Intelligence.
Okay, well, thanks, Blaine and Ramon, for having me. Hey, BTC Pod, super excited to be on. Yes, I'm a tech advisor and investor. I think my area, how I like to summarize it is creators, brands, social, and commerce. Like, those are the things I'm crazy about. I can talk about those things all day, and I think that space is kind of ripe for disruption and some innovation, so I kind of want to be part of that. I worked in big tech my whole life, so I was kind of a big tech girl. I was at Ebay for several years where I really found my love for e commerce, marketplaces, and DTC, in a way. I was in strategy and M A there early in my career and then actually got the cool opportunity to work as an advisor to the CEO on restructuring the business after we spun off PayPal. I was also formerly the head of shopping partnerships at Instagram, so really got to see that go zero to one, and most recently was the global head of partnerships at Snap. So, yeah, lots of war stories, lots of social commerce. So excited to get into it. You guys sweet.
And I'd love to go a little back. Let's go back and start with Ebay maybe, and then we can kind of talk through some of the other experience. But I'd love to know a little bit more. Why don't you just set the scene for us? What was the commerce landscape like? What were you working on at Ebay? What were some of the fun initiatives that you guys were taking on from an M A perspective? And maybe what were some of the early learnings in terms of how that started to influence your career?
And, you know, I really think Ebay is like the OG e commerce website. Like, they started this whole idea of a marketplace and this idea, know, where supply meets demand, where eyeballs meet supply on the Internet. And I sometimes feel like people don't give them enough credit, like they're OGS, they're ballers. And I think they disrupted the Internet in their time. But really what I learned a lot about is how they maintained that flywheel of demand and supply right? Like how they kept the incentives right, how they got the economy, their micro economy going. And so that was really fun to observe firsthand. At my time, what was important was they were trying to get away from the auction model because it was stifling them. So they were trying to move away from that classic auction model towards more like buy, know, buy immediately, again, making them more competitive with modern Amazon et trying.
So Ebay's core categories, which they're still really core, are like car parts and memorabilia and hard to find items. And they were at the time trying to move towards more mainstream items, fashion, toys, that kind of stuff. So it was a lot of that and a lot of just transitioning that model where Ebay started thinking a lot more critically about the inventory they maintained on the site and working closely with sellers to maintain supply and stuff like that. It was a really cool time.
Yeah, it's interesting because back then, community or creators weren't a thing, right? It was black and white, supply and demand. It was the buyers and the as a, as a previous marketplace founder, I'm curious, and given that Snap and Instagram, in a way, they're kind of marketplaces, but Ebay is a very wrong, like, your definition of a marketplace. What were some of the elements, what did you learn about flywheel and what were some of the elements that really made the flywheel go at that big part there, too.
Yeah, so PayPal was a big part of it. But it's funny because we had creators at Ebay they were just power. Like those were our know. It was these random people in the middle of nowhere who had World War II memorabilia and would make a lot of money on it. And they were part of this Ebay community. We used to go talk to sellers. There was this very avid community of sellers that kind of impacted sales, but not just that kind of like the feel and the look and feel, if you will, of Ebay. And that was a thing.
So I feel like the OG creator were these power. You know, Ebay did a really good job of cultivating their community and listening to them and honestly, they showed a lot of care to their creators. I don't think the same can be said about Instagram et cetera, right now, and we can get into it, but I think it was like they really start cultivating that kind of culture of care. And then when you think about the flywheel to your question, Ramon, I think it's like the chicken and egg. Right. So the classic marketplace conundrum, if you will, is what comes first, the chicken or the egg, the supply or the demand. Right? And I think a lot of people think of it as demand first. At least social platforms now prioritize demand, right? We need to go where the users are. Once the users are on a platform, then we can start doing partnerships, we can get content, we can do supply, that kind of stuff. And so I think the classic answer to the chicken and wheel is demand. But what I'd say is that Ebay really cultivated that supply base and I think they did it in a way that marketplaces don't do it now. They talked to their sellers, they incentivized them. There was a very tight knit seller community that I think is unique and probably what differentiated Ebay.
Yeah. And one of the power dynamics I think they had is that the supply can be the demand and the demand can be the supply. Meaning like, the buyer can become a seller finds out, oh, I can sell my stuff here. So you don't have to sort of set two go to market motions at the same time. And sometimes those are dynamics you don't think about when starting a marketplaces. And are some things that make it really hard to scale a marketplace. If you have to acquire both sides, you have to find product market fit twice to not make this a marketplace. Podcast.
I'm so down.
Yeah.
We could go on what you mentioned about, for example, Instagram being different with the creator side of things. I want to dive into that, but I want to take a step back at the definition of what a creator is. Right. I feel like it's thrown around so much today. And so what do you define as a creator? Is it a content creator or an example is like a creator can be a power seller on Ebay? How do you define mean?
I think creator is a term started with influencer, right? It was someone who's pushing out content and that kind of became the creator. But I think of creators as voices in the community, like who are big voices in your community and who's driving kind of movements in your community. And in Ebay's case, those were those big sellers, those power sellers. They also had really big buyers who were part of the community, who spoke up, who there were newsletters, there were like forums. It was like this very weird, quirky community and there was like drama. People would talk poorly about other power sellers. To put it simply, they were really tight knit and it was in fact a community. So yeah, a creator is a voice and a voice that impacts, I think, the marketplace or the platform.
One thing that I just wanted to kind of jump in on that you got my mind sort of going, Megan, in terms of marketplaces is I think we've seen so many startups try to go after these social commerce sort of plays, right? And I think the one point you made about Ebay is they spend so long cultivating a really strong seller experience and a really strong supply base of all these different sellers and it's something that's really hard to bootstrap overnight, especially when you're dealing with two sided marketplace dynamics. So it's just like a really good lesson, I think, even in terms of as we see all these social commerce platforms popping up and live selling and all these platforms that are trying to go after it, it almost seems like a good place to start.
And I'm curious if you ever saw this at Ebay. Were people ever building apps on top of Ebay's infrastructure or anything like that? Is that something that you guys ever thought about where you could have different formats like plug into Ebay's existing selling infrastructure?
Yeah, I mean, I don't remember ever working on APIs or white labeling the product, but I think there was so much opportunity with Ebay. And look, I mean, the reality is Ebay is still around. They do live selling, they're in the conversation, they're in the mix. But they lost a lot of market share. Right. And I don't know what caused it because the company was functional, the marketplace was healthy. I don't know where the strategy went wrong. I suspect a lot has to do with the fact that they lost PayPal and it kind of took the wind out of their system. It just was a lot of pressure on the bottom line and their golden goose was PayPal. That kind of enabled them to be creative and play and care in the business. And I agree that when you're kickstarting a marketplace for any other platform, it's really hard. Right. And I think say you're going demand first. How are you as a platform going to be considerate of and intentional of the supply. And something I write a lot about and speak a lot about is that the platforms today, they're not intentional about the supply. They treat the supply as just the supply interchangeable. And the reality is, I'm a former partnerships person, so I have a bias. But I think the reality is the more you minimize the importance of that supply, they're going to go elsewhere. And now going off track. But I still think it's part of the conversation here. Now, the suppliers, the content creators, the sellers, whoever they are, and the audience, they don't need instagram in a way they used to to be connected. These people can find them, demand can find supply elsewhere. And so I think it's a true marketplace in that it's getting democratized and these bigger platforms are going to have to fight harder to retain their demand and supply both.
So what are some of the ways that you suggest early founders to evangelize their community to find the unique traits? Because I don't believe it's like this article on how to build community. There has to be unique traits that you need to identify in your community to build it. So how do you suggest to founders to go about building their community and making it unique?
So I think what's really interesting is the rise now of supply first platforms, and I'm referring to Patreon OnlyFans, et cetera, because what they're doing is they're switching the model from an instagram, right? And they're prioritizing the needs of the quote unquote supply the content creators. And so taking the content creators first in mind, they're now creating the incentives and benefits whereby the content creators can bring their audiences to the platform. So I think, like new founders, they just need to really think about where their sweet spot is. Is it in demand or is it in supply? And second, even if it's in supply, be really thoughtful and intentional about how you incentivize that demand in and how to keep them in that flywheel, because I think it's really easy and lazy if Patreon only cared about its creators and didn't think about the audience that the creators are to. So I think you have to be really authentic and intentional, and I don't mean those in a cliche way. I think it's really being thoughtful about that community you're building and the incentive you're setting up. Sorry. Why? I'm not on.
Do not disturb. Sorry, guys. Hopefully you can edit that out. I'm on. Do not disturb.
Now, Ramon, the other thing I was going to mention in like Megan, both Ramon and I have experience building supply driven marketplaces. And this was something that we like the first marketplace I started was restaurant booking marketplace, where rather than having every single restaurant, we needed a huge supply of restaurants, but we also needed to be very intentional with them. And Ramon, I think you saw this in trend as well. When you guys were building it, you actually filtered out the supplies who were creators in your stance. So rather than just have a whole bunch of creators, you wanted to prioritize the ones that were really good. Megan, in the scale of something like an Instagram or a Facebook or a like, the demand is like, you guys are clearly a demand driven marketplace because the scale is just so insane. But I think in terms of what you're saying and what you're seeing in some of these other creator platforms is they're starting to build these more authentic niche vertical marketplaces around the supply side of things.
Yeah, it's really interesting. You just reminded me of a trend I saw when I was at Ebay, which is Ebay was the supermarketplace right in the beginning. But then what started happening is niches started being created within that space. So Etsy started right, a marketplace for handcrafted goods, and then more recently, of course, but there were others goat for sneakers. And so basically all the verticals in Ebay became their own apps or businesses. And so similarly right, I kind of in real time and now am now putting that or conflating it with what's happening with Instagram, which is you're not satisfying the supply. The supply is going to go elsewhere. You're not satisfying the demand.
People are going to find more intimate social networks like be real or whatever it is right now. So I think it's going to be that spreading out of kind of people and supply and that's going to really change the dynamics. I mean, that's really what I'm betting my career on as well right now. Things are going to get really interesting.
Yeah, it's kind of like the unbundling of whichever way you want to use the word of Ebay and Instagram. But then you have platforms know even whatnot like is whatnot fashion only or are they horizontal? I can't remember exactly.
So I think they're focused on hard to find items, but they are expanding and they're trying to be global. But if you think about it, live shopping right now is pretty verticalized. You kind of have shops, which is luxury whatnot? Which is a lot of memorabilia, hard to find items, pop shops live, which I believe is more fast fashion. So yeah, it is kind of interesting that they start verticalized and then the question is, are they going to stay verticalized? Are they going to come together, merge or join or a big platform would kind of absorb that functionality or that company.
Yeah, it's interesting how I wonder if it's like so for Instagram shopping, for example, where it's like how has it been that long for Instagram to make it work? Is it a blessing and a curse that they already have the supply almost and they're trying to plug in a marketplace because whatnot and all these other are building the supply with the experience as it's growing and it's like, well, we have the biggest supply in the world, but it's like, is that also their.
How?
How has that played?
Totally. Yeah, I think that's such a good point, Ramon, because you think about where demand is and you're like, naturally we just layer on supply and that's going to be a functional I mean, I have the stories of Instagram shopping not working that way, right? And if you really zoom out, you guys probably are familiar with the concept of jobs to be done, right? And for your users or for your listeners, the idea is that a product has a specific job that its users are hiring it to do. Right? And so in Instagram's case, users are hiring Instagram to watch their friends'content or follow their content creators. And then when you layer on different jobs, you confuse the users. And I think at a fundamental level, with Instagram shopping, we were conflating our jobs to be done. We were confused. People were coming to the platform to interact with friends and creators, and then we were throwing a shopping experience at them when perhaps that wasn't in alignment. And so, yeah, I think that's a super fair point.
And when you build from the ground up, like whatnot, you have that job to be done nailed as opposed to trying to just throw it onto your thriving marketplace. The reality is, though, it's like throwing spaghetti on the wall in Instagram where there's so many users that your numbers might still be higher than whatnot? Because even if the conversion is lower, the numbers, the raw numbers are higher. But then long term, do you develop or lose that relationship of trust and delivering to your users what they're looking for? And I think that's like the big question, the open question, if you will, with Instagram for the future.
Yeah. It's because the intent of when they join and the intent of when they use the platform is not the same than what you maybe want it to. You know, I think this is a valuable conversation for the listeners because there's all this talk about DTC brands even having media arms and properties and acquiring existing audience, et cetera. And it sounds really good in theory, but in practice, it's really hard to just turn on the switch and monetize the audience from and then haven't changed their consumer behavior to an alternate sacked when they were there to previously get educated or connect with other people, et cetera. I have one question on the commerce side of Instagram. Isn't the other side of the coin like, well, how do ads work if there's no intent there, then how are people buying things on ads? They must surely want to buy it from the shopping experience.
Yeah, so I think there's a couple of things there. First is with Instagram shopping, we were forcing checkout. And remember, when you force Instagram or Meta checkout, you're asking users to give Meta their credit card information, all this stuff that people have never done before. It's asking a lot from your users. And second, it's about how things are delivered, the algorithms that power the ad that's based on your interest. So a lot of the times the ads are really successful, right? Because we've all probably impulsively bought a sock or something stupid from Instagram ads, right, because the targeting is so good. But when you get Instagram Shopping organic content in your know, it's off putting. It's not what you were expecting in your feed, right? Again, back to that jobs to be done.
It's not an ad. This is a creator you follow, but then suddenly there's like a collaboration organic post where the brand is trying to sell you something with the creator in it. It's a confusing experience. Don't get me wrong. I still believe that Instagram Shopping can be a huge player, if not the main player in social commerce. It's just that it needs time. And I felt like the company was just getting impatient for revenue, but it needed more time to find product market fit.
One thing that I wanted to jump in and say, I know we'd been talking about whatnot Ramona? I was chatting with my friend who works there and whatnot actually had their retreat in Miami last week. So we were catching up and he was telling me all about how they build their supply and what their focus is on. And actually they said a couple of things that you guys had mentioned. One, they're really focused on things like Pokemon collectibles, like these sort of things because there's these niche communities. So one of the biggest areas that people are watching are these card unboxing where it's like sports car memorabilia and they'll unbox the cards. And then it's almost like this community layer too, where you'll get these big groups of buyers that come in and everyone's like, oh, I'm going to have card one in this opening. I'm going to have card two, I'm going to have card three. And they'll open it so that way everyone sees.
So it's like a really engaging thing. And the other thing, Ramon, that will probably resonate with you a little bit. They're really focused on monitoring their supply side of things. So they're not just letting anyone sell whatever, let anyone go live. So they have a really exhaustive creator vetting process. So that goes into what we've been talking about, know, building out that supply. And Megan, to your point, one thing that I think is really interesting, it's like we saw Instagram Shopping, which was really released within Instagram, but then we also saw Meta doing things like rolling out their Threads platform, which is almost like a different take. It's like, okay, maybe our jobs to be done isn't exactly text content, but what if we take a swing at it and take our user base and almost create their own community and whatever.
And I'd be curious. You're probably a little bit closer to the ground than we are a couple of months out after launch. I think what they launch in July, I want to say early July, but I'd be curious in terms of if you know anything of how the platform is progressing. When I saw it first come out, I was like, okay, wow, there's a lot of hype. Amazing onboarding, easy to get there. But the one thing about a social network is it needs to be organic and needs to be a real network. You can't fake or bootstrap. It's really hard to bootstrap or fake a social so, like, I think Ramon and I had a podcast and we were talking about it and I thought Threads was going to work.
I just thought it was going to take a lot more time because you're going to push it out to everyone and then you'd have all these groups sort of form and they need time to cook and bake and build their own thing. It wasn't going to be a Twitter killer overnight. But I'd be curious if you had any insight in terms of the company strategy. They're rolling it out and what your take is on that as a platform.
Well, here's a question. Do either of you use Threads actively?
I don't. I think that's the problem, that there was no onboarding. The onboarding was too frictionless. It was click a button, there's no buy in. And it's much harder to reactivate a churned cohort than actually have people be onboarded onto the experience. I know the question was if I'm using it on my personal take on it, but there it is.
No, I love it. What about you, Blade?
Yeah, I probably use it a little more than of I'm a lurker. I'll pop in, I'll see what's going on. I'm not writing and creating content. We were doing some stuff on it for a while, even from some of our business accounts and stuff like that in terms of creating content and testing it. But yeah, I put myself more in the lurker category, but lurker but interested.
Yeah, so it's really funny. I'm asking because I was so bullish on breads in the like I was out talking to the BBC, I was in the Wall Street Journal. I was like, guys, this is the next big thing and this is huge. And the frictionless onboarding and I'm kind of like biting my tongue a little because well, first of all, I stand by what I say, meaning that it was a great move, it was timely and the onboarding was great. But then there's the flip side to Ramon's point, which know, was it too easy to onboard and was it almost like a dow hack or like a growth hack. And I think that so much of what they do with threads is like growth hacking. Where with Snap, for example, if you guys still use Snap, they have memories, right? Those are growth hacks just to get you back on the platform to view your memories for over 30 seconds daily, active user. And so a lot of the thread stuff, it just feels like growth hacking now.
And I'll go on threads because I miss Twitter, I really miss scrolling, something text based. So I think it is satisfying that need and I think it's clear in its jobs to be done because it's a separate app, which is great. But I agree there was no buy in to download and install and I think that funnel is going to be really interesting to see where it goes and I don't know, I'd be really curious to see what their active users are right now.
Yeah, I was really bullish too. I hope it works. I really wanted to I think text is such a different form of media that we crave. Text is interpreted different by everyone. There's so many different dynamics of text as media that it has that I think there's definitely room. I mean, it's their best chance, right? It was a great move, is their best chance for creating a new media property, for getting more money from advertisers and I hope it works. My challenge was that I was being fed on my feet just like People magazine and things that I have no interest in. But don't underestimate having a huge audience.
Maybe they fix it around, add web app and go from there.
But I'm curious, that's the point. Really quickly, before I forget, sorry to interrupt. Is it's like the people you follow on Instagram you automatically followed on threads, right? But then those jobs to be done are different, right? So like I love people on Instagram because I get the pictures and stuff, but I don't really care what they have for sure. My Twitter is all politics and tech and that's what I would want my threads to be as well. But it's a lot more pop culture and shopping and brands than I would have wanted. So that's the other issue, right?
And it's really hard to revert that. I mean, you already had my account is like oh shit, my high school friends are also on here now. I don't want that. So what do you do? You can't undo that. And that goes back to the effortless one click onboarding of everyone, et cetera. I know you. Mentioned Snap, and I'm curious on the different dynamics. It seems like Snap really understands their job to be done.
Right.
They really drive almost to a fault, though.
Yeah, okay.
I would love to learn more.
Well, I think Snap is it's a classic example, in my opinion, of just this perfect understanding of their users and just a great simple app, right? Like, it really understands the demographics. Twelve to 21. It's fun, it's quirky. The UX is kind of weird, but it's like intentionally weird, right? Because grown ups can't be using it, adults can't be using it, and that kind of thing. But the problem is, when you're so good at that niche and you're so good at that specific job, it makes it really hard to expand. And I think during my time at Snap, we tried over and over again to build a business value prop, or to expand into deals on maps or try new products. AR shopping was a really big push. But the problem is, it was so hard for anyone to think of Snap as anything other than a silly messaging app.
And silly I'm using intentionally, right? Like, to be funny with your friends or quirky. It was really hard to change users impression of Snap, but I think it's been easier with Instagram, with certain features.
Yeah, I agree with that. I feel like actually, it's funny that you say it's like the user base. Twelve to 21 and almost intentionally, because I was right in probably that first cohort of Snap users where I was in college. I downloaded it right when it came out. I think it was, what, like 2013 or 14, something like that. And then slowly, as the product evolved, I found myself, I was like, oh, man, I'm getting old. I don't even know how to use Snapchat anymore. But maybe that was a little bit intentional.
But it seems like I'd also love to have a better understanding of what you guys were trying to accomplish from the partnership side, right? Because as the product evolved, there was things know, the medias, the like, why don't you just cue me and Ramon and obviously the audience in on what Snapchat is all about. Because you've got the messaging, you can obviously send the disappearing messaging. I can see where my friends are on the map. I can see the bitmoji. But talk to me a little bit more about what the partnerships initiatives are, what are the media initiatives, all that kind of stuff.
Well, here's the thing, right, to talk about, kind of an underlying theme to our entire conversation is iOS 14. And I know us three have talked about it before, but iOS 14 has just changed the dynamics on these social platforms, but really all platforms. So anything ad revenue based so intensely that I think everyone's doing a little bit of a strategy pivot. So that was kind of the context in which I joined Snap where they're like, oh shit, this thing is going to take away all of our data. We have no PII anymore. We're losing revenue right and left. Advertisers are leaving marketers drop. Snap, they're the first to go from the share of wallet.
Right. Because it's a niche demographic. So Snap was hit really hard as compared to Facebook, et cetera. So the whole strategy was how do we expand our offering, how do we monetize beyond ads? And frankly, how do we, with the ads we have, get users to stay in the app longer? And I think that's a super reasonable goal. And I think you can say that all platforms were thinking about this, but all tried different strategies. So one of the things I was working on at Snap, for example, was AR shopping. So the idea with AR shopping is Snap truly does have best in class or very good AR technology. And so how do you leverage that to get someone into a buying experience? The goal, of course, is to have them spend more time in Snap, open the app more often, and then hopefully entice advertisers to use organic products so that they spend more on Snap.
Right. It's kind of this very simple strategy where every new product we launched or every new partnership we launched was about driving that bottom line number. And so that's what a lot of what I was focused on. And it's tough. I mean, we were prepping for iOS 14 at Meta years before it came out. And I think Snap didn't do that kind of work up front, candidly and they were struggling and scrambling when it launched to just, oh my God, let's try this, let's try that, let's try this, in order to drive revenue. And so that was kind of the context. And so that was a lot of the deals that I did and my time spent there.
Yeah. Miguel, it seems based on all of your experience with commerce and all of this, given all of this, what is it that excites you now? What are the commerce applications that you are most excited about today and get you fired up?
Yeah, well, first, being a big company, big tech girl my whole career, I took a big risk kind of going out on my own and being so embedded in the startup ecosystem. But I'm truly putting my money where my mouth is. I'm betting on the future generation of social commerce and creator companies. I think the reality is, as we talked about, these platforms aren't doing what they were supposed to do or could do to support their communities. So, like, a reckoning is coming and I'm trying to be in on that. The stuff specifically that excites me is I know creators were really hot a year ago and now investors don't want to talk about them. But there's still a lot that can be done to enable or monetize creators, and not just in the photo or image space. It can be podcasts, it can be creating businesses, it could be creating merch.
There's just so much there social commerce, I'm still like my passion is still social commerce and if anyone could have done it, it should have been Instagram and they didn't. So there's now a lot of time before they try again where someone new can kick start something and then just social networks, period. Right? I think it's been really interesting intellectually following the rise and fall of Be Real of Fizz is kind of a new emerging startup at Stanford campus that's expanding. So just all these new social networks emerging because know, Facebook is dead, instagram is more media than social, snap is super niche, YouTube is content consumption. So is like where am I interacting with my friends? Is it just, you know so I think that's going to be really interesting.
So what does that look like, the future of commerce that you.
Think? And I've written about this a lot too. I think the future of commerce is like the past a little where we were overly betting on Instagram and YouTube to solve commerce and dictate the future of shopping. Whereas now what I see with a lot of the brands I work with or businesses I advise, they want to take traffic back to their website and they're really interested in doing pop up shops like Omnichannel is it again, right. And Omnichannel was something we didn't talk about for five years, but we were talking about five plus years ago. So I think it's a little bit of this regression back into what used to work tried and true methods and then also dropping a lot of methods that used to work, like paid media. Right? The whole customer acquisition game on social is really changing and so marketers are spending less of their money on Instagram, for example, and redirecting that towards their creators, their communities beyond Yoga did like a walk in Santa Monica that had like 60 people show up and it was a walk, it was a free activation. But again, it's these hyper local community activations and again back to basics that I think brands are playing with and I think it's getting really interesting again.
Yeah, I lived for a few years in Austin and the founder of Outdoor Voices, Ty Haney I think is her name. It's crazy. She's doing another brand that's like a healthy energy drink and it's the same playbook. It's activations and runs and just getting really riled up. And it's just wonderful to watch her because it's a superpower and it's what we were talking about five years ago, but we went through sort of this gap and now that's what it is. Again, another interesting one I've seen is, and this is just for DTC brands to find ways to not depend so much on apps because of what you mentioned of iOS 14. What's that platform where you connect with all your neighbors. I forget.
Next door.
Yeah.
So next door. And I saw people hiring people on nextdoor to promote to their community, like a meal delivery service, et cetera. And so it's just brands need to think outside of the Facebook and Instagram world. However, on that note, I want to hear your thoughts on how you're thinking about content. As an arm of, you know, organic content is working so well. Creators are playing a part in that. You know, this is what my previous marketplace was, which is pretty much like hiring creators to do your own UGC so you can build your own distribution. So how should brands be thinking about creating their own content to build their own.
Think? I've thought about this a lot, actually. So thank you for asking that. And I think, really, the future of brand building and marketing in kind of a post iOS 14, post platform world is these three C's, right? It's content creators and community. It's not paid media, it's not Ads, it's not the Playbook 1.0. Like, I think this is the new Playbook, right? So it's about let's start with content. To your point, Ramon, it's about authentic content, not oversaturating your viewers or users with pushes to sell or random content. It's about authentic content that really speaks to your brand voice. It's about using the right creators that align with your community, that speak the same language as you, that spread the same message and values as you.
And then, third, it's about really putting that community first. Right? It's about what does that community want and taking that upwards. Feedback into the brand, building into the products, into the messaging, and staying really tight with your community. And to a certain extent, this all existed post iOS 14. But I think the importance of all of this is just on a much bigger scale now than it ever was.
Yeah. And that's where AI comes into play. It's like, well, if content is the move, how do you reduce the friction layers to generating more content? I get really excited about this because this is why Blaine and I are building Castmagic. It's audio we thought was the easiest way to remove friction. And even for our creators that we're hiring. At Castmagic, Blaine and I, if we have a product launch or feature launch, we will record a call between him and I, like, announcing, explaining the entire feature, and then we'll get the transcript and the outputs and send them to our creators. So they're really in touch with every single thing about the product. And I think brands should definitely be leveraging AI to repurpose a lot of content and continue to reduce the barriers to content because it is expensive to make content completely.
Agreed. And I think there's a real big nuance there, which is in terms of content creation, yes, AI can kind of make it more seamless and get it out to market quickly, but then at the same time, you have to really still be careful to embody that voice, know, carry that message forward authentically.
Yeah. And I think, Megan, you hit the nail on the head there, and that's something we think a lot about. It's like, how can AI work alongside the creator? So you can maintain the authenticity right, where it's you you've screened everything and you're like, if I'm pressing on publish on this, this better sound exactly like me, and I better stand by everything this says. So, yeah, I think it's really interesting. And the other thing I'd say is this playbook that you're talking about, about what was it was community creators and content. Right. This playbook can be applied. And it's the same playbook that we're applying to a bootstrap, SaaS company that you can apply to a direct to consumer company that you can apply if you're a VC backed founder and you're founding a B to B company.
Right, totally. I think that framework is and that's what we see the best companies doing. It's been fueling our growth and it's fueling some of the fastest growing companies out there. So I love that in terms of how you're able to distill it, make it really easy to remember.
Yeah. I mean, I'm also predicting that it's a moment for DTC. Like DTC, it was really hot for a while, then it became not cool. And I think it's going to be very in vogue going forward. I'm betting a lot on it. So I think your viewership is just going to blow up. So everyone tune into the DTC Pod because it's the hottest podcast.
I love that. Well, anyway, as we wrap up here, Megan, are there any other things on the horizon for you? Other last things you're interested in? I know we didn't really get too far into TikTok. I'd also love as we wrap up, just to hear your quick take on how that fits within the commerce ecosystem, because a lot of the creator initiatives that we see, and that we see brands going after, especially in D to C, and their ad platform is TikTok. So would love to maybe hear what you have to say about TikTok. And if there's any other last things that you'd like to go over, happy to cover those as well.
Totally. So TikTok is you got to be there, right? So everyone needs to be on TikTok. All the brands I talk to are there. I think the real open question, though, is not about their viability as a platform. That's a given. It's around TikTok shops. And I'm really curious. I'm watching it very closely because they have a huge opportunity because there's so much trust between creators and their users on TikTok, that community is very strong.
So there's a big opportunity to translate that into conversions and purchases. But they can also fall into the same traps that we did at Instagram, at snap and every other platform that's unsuccessfully tried shopping. So I'm hoping they're going to be very intentional and thoughtful about how they approach shopping. I know they are getting a little more involved in fulfillment than other platforms. They have a lot of partners with Chinese manufacturers as well, so there's a lot of nuance to the way they're launching it. But I'll be watching closely to see if they fall into some common traps. Final words. I think everyone needs to go support their brands, their DTC brands and their creators shop on their websites for now.
And I think it's important you as a user, to just think about where am I spending a lot of my time? Am I spending less time on Instagram? I certainly am. And instead, I'm following my creators to wherever they go. I'm listening to more podcasts. So I think that trend is going to affect all of us, and I'm really curious to see how it all plays out.
I have one takeaway one prediction question for you before we go, which is you think X.com is going to become the Everything app and pull off the WeChat of the that?
I think Elon Musk has stated that's his you know, he is a you know, he could very easily or has the experience to bring in the payments infrastructure. And so I guess the answer is yes, it can easily become the super app. But then the other question is, who's going to be using it?
A bunch of words. Yeah, for sure. Well, we'll have to do a rerun in the future after and break it down after we see how it goes down.
I feel like I could talk to you guys forever. We need to hang out. This was so fun.
Well, we will at the event and we're shouting out here this will be the first episode that we're shouting it out. We are throwing a DTC Pod event in La. So if you're interested in coming, there's only a couple of invites left DM, me or Ramon, and we'll get you on the list. But Megan is going to be there as well as a whole bunch of other guests that have been on our Pod, so we're really excited for that. That's coming up October 5. And last thing before we go, Megan, where can our listeners find you and connect with you? Why don't you shout out your social so we know where to find you?
Yeah. So you guys, I'm really all about LinkedIn right now. I feel like LinkedIn is my new ex or my don't don't add me on Snap. Isn't that like a red flag? If a guy asks for your Snap, you're like, so yeah, find me on LinkedIn. I'm on Instagram, but it's mostly my social stuff. I'm at Meghana and then LinkedIn is just my full name. So, yeah, check me out. I write a lot.
Awesome. Thanks so much for coming on the Pod megan, we had a great time.
Thank you.
Thanks for tuning in and we hope you enjoyed this episode of DTC Pod. If you enjoyed the show, we'd love your support. A rating and review would go a long way as we continue to host the best builders in DTC and beyond. Follow and subscribe to the show and make sure to check out our show notes. Where you can find our socials and weekly newsletter, visit us on dtcpod.com to join.
Also generated
More from this recording
1️⃣ One Sentence Summary
Examining social commerce: Instagram's missteps, eBay's success, and TikTok's potential.
💬 Keywords
Instagram shopping, supply based on demand, jobs to be done, platform confusion, starting from scratch, Whatnot, trust and user experience, eBay, original e-commerce website, marketplace, flywheel of demand and supply, micro-economy, transitioning away from auction model, expanding into mainstream items, critical inventory maintenance, big tech companies, startup ecosystem, community support, social commerce, creator companies, alternative platforms, iOS 14, ad revenue, Snap, data and revenue loss, bottom line, PayPal, considerate supply, larger platforms, TikTok, shopping traps, intentional approach, eBay creators.
🔑 7 Key Themes
"Jobs to be done" concept in product development.
Instagram's shift to shopping and user confusion.
The importance of starting from scratch for new platforms.
eBay's disruptive impact on the marketplace model.
The need for better support of communities on current platforms.
The potential of social commerce and monetizing creators.
The rise and fall of new social networks and their impact.
📚 Timestamped overview
03:39 eBay: OG e-commerce site, disrupted Internet, transitioning away from auctions, expanding categories, maintaining supply.
05:42 PayPal was an important part of eBay's success. eBay had a community of sellers who impacted sales and the overall feel of the platform. eBay prioritized cultivating a tight-knit seller community, unlike other social platforms. The supply of sellers was crucial for eBay's success, unlike the current focus on demand.
10:46 eBay lost market share due to losing PayPal, neglecting supply importance, and competition from other platforms. Marketplaces are becoming more democratized.
13:10 The rise of supply-first platforms prioritizes content creators and creates incentives for audience engagement. Founders should focus on their sweet spot and be intentional about building an authentic community.
18:06 Instagram confused users by adding a shopping experience, which conflicted with their main goal of interacting with friends and creators. Building a platform from the ground up with a clear purpose is more effective, despite potential short-term gains. The future of Instagram relies on maintaining user trust and delivering what they want.
22:16 My friend said Ramona, the company had a retreat in Miami. They focus on Pokemon collectibles and have a strict creator vetting process. They're launching a platform similar to Instagram Shopping and Meta's Threads. Curious about the platform's progress and company strategy.
26:20 The text discusses the author's initial enthusiasm for a new platform and their concerns about its growth hacking strategies and user engagement. They also express curiosity about the current number of active users.
30:54 The speaker agrees and relates their experience as an early Snapchat user. They express curiosity about the company's partnership and media initiatives.
32:00 iOS 14 changed social platforms, impacting ad revenue. Snap struggled and focused on expanding offerings and increasing app usage. One strategy was AR shopping. The goal was to drive revenue and entice advertisers. Preparations for iOS 14 were lacking, leading to scrambling for revenue.
36:34 The future of commerce is shifting back to traditional methods and away from relying on Instagram and YouTube. Brands are focusing on driving traffic to their websites and utilizing pop-up shops. There is less emphasis on paid media and more investment in community activations.
39:39 The future of brand building and marketing is content creators, community, and putting the community first in a post iOS 14 world. Authentic content is key.
44:11 TikTok's viability as a platform is unquestionable. The real question is around TikTok shops and their potential for conversions. They should be careful not to repeat past shopping failures. Brands and creators should focus on website shopping for now, and users should consider where they spend their time.
46:36 We're hosting a DTC Pod event in LA with guests including Megan, on October 5. Limited invites available, DM for details.
📚 Timestamped overview
03:39 ebay: OG e-commerce, disruptive, evolving inventory.
05:42 PayPal, creators, sellers: eBay's unique community culture.
10:46 eBay lost market share due to PayPal.
13:10 Supply-first platforms prioritize content creators, incentivizing their audiences.
18:06 Instagram shopping confused users' expectations and needs.
22:16 Platform focuses on niche communities and monitoring supply.
26:20 Funny, bullish on breads, onboarding frictionless, growth hacking, satisfying, interesting funnel, curious active users.
30:54 Agreed Snap user asks about partnerships and media.
32:00 iOS 14 shook social platforms, including Snap. Snap faced challenges due to loss of data and ad revenue. They aimed to expand offerings and increase user engagement. AR shopping was one strategy pursued. The goal was to drive revenue and partnerships were crucial. Snap was unprepared for iOS 14 and scrambled for solutions.
36:34 Commerce shifting towards website traffic and pop-ups.
39:39 Content creators, community, and authentic content.
44:11 TikTok's potential for shopping: worth watching.
46:36 DTC Pod event in LA on October 5.
❇️ Key topics and bullets
Topics Covered in the Text:
I. Adding Shopping Features to Social Platforms
A. Instagram as an Example
B. "Jobs to be Done" Concept
C. Instagram Users' Hiring Purpose
D. Confusion and Misalignment of Shopping Features
E. Starting from Scratch with New Platforms
II. The Impact of Adding Shopping Features
A. Initial High Numbers vs. Long-term Trust and User Experience
B. eBay's Role as the Original E-commerce Website
C. eBay's Disruptive Nature and Micro-economy
D. eBay's Transition and Expansion
E. eBay's Focus on Supply and Collaboration with Sellers
III. The Speaker's Journey and the Future of Startups
A. Transition from Big Tech Companies to the Startup Ecosystem
B. Inadequate Support of Communities on Current Platforms
C. Excitement for Social Commerce and Creator Companies
D. Opportunities to Enable and Monetize Creators
IV. Dynamics on Social Platforms and Snap's Strategy
A. Impact of iOS 14 on Social Platforms and Ad Revenue
B. Snap's Losses Compared to Facebook
C. Snap's Strategy to Expand and Monetize Beyond Ads
D. AR Shopping and Revenue-generating Strategies
V. eBay's Opportunity and Consideration of Supply
A. eBay's Loss of Market Share and PayPal's Role
B. Importance of Supply in a Marketplace
C. Interchangeability of Supply and Platform Alternatives
VI. The Rise and Fall of Social Networks
A. The Need for Alternative Platforms
B. TikTok's Importance and Potential for Shopping
C. TikTok's Focus and Approach to Shopping
D. Cautionary Approach to Avoid Shopping Traps
VII. Supporting Brands and Creators
A. Shopping on Creators' Websites
B. Following Creators to Different Platforms
C. The "Reckoning" in the Marketplace
VIII. eBay's Community and Approach to Marketplace Dynamics
A. Influence of PayPal and Creators in eBay's Success
B. eBay's Culture of Care for Creators
C. Different Approach to Marketplace Dynamics
IX. Instagram Shopping and Product-Market Fit
A. User Onboarding Challenges and Success
B. Rushing for Revenue vs. Organic Development
C. Comparison with Meta's Threads Platform
X. Whatnot's Focus and Community Engagement
A. Niche Communities and Live Openings
B. Monitoring Supply and Creator Vetting Process
XI. Curiosity about Threads and User Engagement
A. Initial Enthusiasm and Promotion of Threads
B. Concerns of Growth Hacking
C. Comparison to Snap's Growth Techniques
D. Use of Threads for Text-based Needs
E. Tracking User Engagement and Active Users
🎬 Reel script
[Opening shot: You holding a microphone]
You: Hey there, entrepreneurs and business influencers! It's time for a quick recap of our latest episode on the DTC Pod. I had the pleasure of hosting a fascinating discussion with tech advisor and investor Meghana Dhar. Here are the highlights in just 45 seconds!
[Cut to fast-paced clips matching the key points]
Point 1: Meghana agreed with Ramon that adding supply based on demand might not always work. Case in point: Instagram shopping.
Point 2: They introduced the concept of "jobs to be done" - think of products being hired to fulfill a specific purpose.
Point 3: Instagram users primarily hire the platform to watch friends' and content creators' content.
Point 4: Adding shopping features to Instagram confused users, as it deviated from their original purpose.
Point 5: Meghana believes starting fresh with a platform like Whatnot, where the job to be done is clear, is more effective.
Point 6: They highlighted eBay's disruptive impact on the internet and praised their strong supply-demand flywheel.
Point 7: Platforms should be considerate and intentional about the supply to retain both demand and supply.
Point 8: Meghana expressed excitement about the potential of social commerce and creator companies.
[Closing shot: You smiling and holding up a sign with "DTC Pod" logo]
You: And that's a wrap! Be sure to check out the full episode on the DTC Pod for more insights from Meghana Dhar. Stay tuned for more valuable content. Until next time! #DTCPod #BusinessInfluencer
[End]
✏️ Custom Newsletter
Subject: 🎧 Get Ready to Dive into the World of Social Commerce with Meghana Dhar | New DTC Pod Episode Out Now! 🚀
Hey there, podcast enthusiasts!
We hope this email finds you ready for yet another thrilling episode of DTC Pod! In this week's episode, our hosts Blaine Bolus and Ramon Berrios sit down with the incredible tech advisor and investor, Meghana Dhar. Get ready to dive headfirst into the fascinating world of social commerce and the behind-the-scenes dynamics of popular platforms like Instagram and Snap.
So, grab your headphones and let's get started!
🎧 Listen to the latest episode: [Insert Podcast Episode Link]
🔑 Here are 5 key takeaways you won't want to miss from our conversation with Meghana Dhar:
1️⃣ The importance of understanding the "jobs to be done" concept in product development and how it can help shape successful platforms and experiences.
2️⃣ The intriguing rise and fall of new social networks and the need for alternative platforms for connecting with friends and creators.
3️⃣ How eBay disrupted the internet and the strategies they employed to create a thriving micro-economy.
4️⃣ The impact of iOS 14 on social platforms and the challenges faced by Snap in adapting their revenue generation strategies.
5️⃣ The potential of TikTok as a social commerce powerhouse and the careful approach they are taking to balance user trust and shopping experiences.
🌟 Fun Fact: Did you know that eBay was the original e-commerce website and deserves more credit for revolutionizing the marketplace concept? Discover how they cultivated a tight-knit community, listened to their sellers, and disrupted the industry!
🔕 Outtro: As our conversation with Meghana Dhar draws to a close, we reflect on the future of social commerce and the need for platforms to support their communities better. Get ready for an exciting reckoning!
📢 Call to Action: Want to learn more about the fascinating world of social commerce? Tune in to the latest episode of DTC Pod on [insert podcast platform of choice] and discover the strategies, challenges, and potential of this ever-evolving landscape. Don't forget to subscribe and share with your fellow podcast junkies!
That's a wrap for this week's episode! As always, we're committed to bringing you captivating discussions and insights from the world of digital commerce.
Stay curious,
[Your Name] and the DTC Pod Team
P.S. Have a burning question or a topic suggestion for a future episode? Don't hesitate to reach out to us on social media or reply to this email. We'd love to hear from you!
🐦 Business Lesson Tweet Thread
Tweet 1: With Instagram Shopping, simplicity got lost in the hunt for revenue. 💔
Tweet 2: Remember the power of "jobs to be done" - people hired Instagram to watch, not shop. 📸
Tweet 3: The rise and fall of social networks opens doors for alternatives 🚪
Tweet 4: TikTok shops hold potential, but let's avoid the shopping traps 🛍️
Tweet 5: eBay disrupted the internet by cultivating a tight-knit creator community. 👥
Tweet 6: Instagram could learn from eBay's care for creators. 🤝
Tweet 7: Platforms, take note: supply is not interchangeable. Treat it with care. 🛒
Tweet 8: PayPal played a crucial role in eBay's success. 💰
Tweet 9: Onboarding may be frictionless, but growth hacking raises questions. ⏩
Tweet 10: Threads offers a satisfying scrolling experience, but we're curious about user engagement. 📜
Tweet 11: The future of the social commerce landscape is in the hands of creators and their communities. 🌟
Tweet 12: It's time for platforms to work harder to retain both demand and supply. 💪
Tweet 13: Let's support brands and creators by shopping on their websites for now. 💻
Tweet 14: Social commerce is evolving - stay tuned for the next chapter! 📚
Tweet 15: The world needs more authentic social networks. Who will rise to the challenge? 🌍
#DTCPOD #SocialCommerce #eBay #InstagramShopping #TikTokShops #CreatorsCommunity #AuthenticNetworks
🎓 Lessons Learned
Supply-first approach drives success
Prioritize cultivating supply base.
eBay's success in building a tight-knit seller community.
Platform purpose drives user experience
Align features with platform purpose.
Instagram's shopping feature confused users.
Community care is crucial
Cultivate and listen to community.
eBay's culture of care for creators.
Intentionality in marketplace dynamics
Treat supply and demand differently.
eBay focused on cultivating supply.
User trust affects shopping experience
Ask for credit card info.
Off-putting when organic content includes shopping.
Opportunities in social commerce
Enable and monetize creators.
Beyond photo/image space (e.g. podcasts, merch).
Rise and fall of social networks
Need for alternative platforms.
Explore new ways to interact with friends.
TikTok's cautious approach to shopping
Thoughtful approach, involved in fulfillment.
Making partnerships with manufacturers.
Prioritizing organic growth over revenue
Allow platform to develop organically.
Rushing for revenue can hinder product-market fit.
Threads' frictionless onboarding raises questions
Growth hacking techniques questioned.
Curiosity about user engagement and current active users.
💎 Maxims
"Venture out of your comfort zone: No path is without risk, but the potential rewards of trying something new might outweigh the security of sticking to the known."
"Support what supports you: If any platform isn't beneficial to its users, it's time to follow the creators to the next platform."
"Embrace the possibilities of new advancements: Social commerce, podcasts, and the creator economy are rising trends embedded with untapped potential."
"Stay adaptable amid new trends: Keep a keen eye on growing platforms like TikTok and explore the business opportunities they present."
"Turn trust into a revenue stream: Foster meaningful relationships between creators and users and leverage them for commerce."
"Promote creator independence: Encourage users to support creators directly for a more equitable digital ecosystem."
"Be intentional with growth: Avoid quick fixes for revenue and focus on organic growth and product-market fit."
"Community over commodity: Cultivate an engaging user community to outshine any product or service."
"Priority to user engagement: A product's success lies in how well it resonates with its users and their needs."
"Every user is unique: Understand that the ease of onboarding might suit some users but not all. Track user engagement diversely."
"Success lies in partnership: Recognize the role of symbiotic relationships, like that of PayPal and eBay, in the growth of the company."
"Not all supply is created equal: Be considerate about the quality and distinctiveness of your supply in a marketplace."
"The future lies in the democratized marketplace: Big platforms will have to work harder to retain demand and supply."
"Value your founding contributors: Like eBay's seller community, every platform has a set of users who play a crucial role in shaping its identity."
"Recognize the pioneers: Acknowledge the precedents set by original innovators like eBay in developing the e-commerce landscape."
"Respond swiftly to external changes: Stay prepared for major updates, like iOS 14, to minimize business disruption."
"Be mindful of the original purpose: When introducing new features, ensure it aligns with what users initially 'hired' the product for."
"Value long-term over short-term gains: Temporary boost in numbers could lead to issues with trust and user experience. Always prioritize sustainability."
🌟 3 Fun Facts
Meghana Dhar took a risk by leaving her role at a big tech company to venture into the startup ecosystem, believing current platforms don't adequately support their communities.
Dhar is passionate about social commerce and has a keen interest in the evolution and potential pitfalls of platforms like TikTok and Instagram, advising users to support brands and creators by shopping on their websites for now.
Revealing an inside look at tech companies, Dhar shared information about a recent retreat hosted by Whatnot in Miami and discussed her involvement with Instagram Shopping and Snap. She also expressed admiration for eBay, citing it as the original e-commerce website that disrupted the internet in its time.
🎤 Voiceover Script
"Join us in this episode of DTC POD as we talk with Meghana Dhar. Meghana dives into how social commerce platforms are evolving, shares insights about her time at Snap and eBay, and discusses the potential pitfalls and promises of Instagram Shopping. Above all, she directs a spotlight on the importance of supporting creators, the essential 'supply' in a marketplace. Tune in to explore how these dynamics will shape the future of commerce and creator businesses."
📓 Blog Post
Title: Conversations on Social Commerce, Creator Markets, and the Future of E-Commerce on DTC Pod
Subheader: With Special Guest, Meghana Dhar
Introduction
In a recent episode of DTC Pod, we were delighted to welcome Meghana Dhar, who shared her insights on a range of issues affecting the tech industry today. From social commerce and the growth of content creators to the future of e-commerce platforms, her expertise brought a fascinating perspective to our conversation.
The Strength and Potential of Social Commerce & Creators
Meghana expressed her excitement over the potential of social commerce and the exponential growth of creator markets. She highlighted the undiscovered opportunities in these spaces beyond the traditional photo or image space, including podcasts, business creation, and merchandising. Her focus on social commerce intertwines with a critique of Instagram's shopping features, stating that the platform could have done better.
Alternatives to Mainstream: The Rise and Fall of Social Networks
Our guest emphasized the importance of understanding the dynamics of new and emerging social networks as they pose alluring alternatives to mainstream platforms. Meghana mentioned TikTok as an essential tool for brands and predicted a significant potential for creators to convert trust with users into purchases. Nonetheless, she also expressed her concern about TikTok falling into the same pitfalls as other platforms such as Instagram and Snapchat.
Whatnot, Breads, And Instagram: A Comparative Analysis
Drawing a comparison between different platforms, Meghana mentioned the strengths of Whatnot in building their supply, especially in niche communities. She also expressed her initial enthusiasm for Breads and spoke about the concept of frictionless onboarding.
Instagram & Threads: Pros, Cons, and What’s Next
Meghana opined that while Instagram Shopping has the potential to dominate the scene of social commerce, the platform must invest more time in understanding market-product compatibility. Furthermore, while Threads is an authentic social network, questions remain concerning user engagement metrics and the platform's overall strategies.
Reflecting on eBay, The Original E-Commerce Website
Meghana justified her strong belief that eBay deserves recognition as a pioneer in creating the marketplace concept online. She outlined her insights about how eBay maintained a balance between demand and supply, and the incentives that created a micro-economy on the platform.
The Future: Social Platforms and the Marketplace Dynamic
In an era of a more democratized marketplace, larger platforms like Instagram are no longer crucial for connecting the supply chain and the demand chain since they can interact elsewhere. According to Meghana, this change will force these platforms to work harder to retain both supply and demand sides less they want to lose to new competitors.
Lessons from Snap: New Strategies Post-iOS 14
Reflecting on her time at Snap, she highlighted how Snap had to quickly develop new strategies to retain revenue after the implementation of iOS 14 took away ad revenue. Initiatives such as AR shopping were fundamental in increasing user retention and attracting advertisers.
Conclusion
Ending the conversation on a high note, Dhar stressed that innovative platforms that fill space where 'jobs are meant to be done' and offer features aligned with users' primary purposes for using them are more likely to be successful than platforms that keep on adding features. Her knowledgeable insights and unique perspectives promised substantial food for thought for both our hosts and listeners, making this episode a must-listen on DTC Pod.
🔘 Best Practices Guide
In developing a robust digital platform, prioritize building a loyal, engaged community akin to eBay's model. Use thoughtful and intentional strategies, like TikTok's careful approach to shopping or Whatnot's exhaustive creator vetting process. Give due importance to supply and not just demand, as interchangeable suppliers might switch platforms. Provide features adhering to the principle of "jobs to be done," focusing on what users primarily want. Embedding non-aligned features like shopping into a photo content platform might confuse users and impact trust negatively. Instead, consider creating an entirely new platform with clear objectives. Monitor changes, like iOS 14, and their impacts on ad revenues and user behavior. Learn from Snap's example to formulate proactive strategies. Lastly, enable and monetize creators beyond traditional areas, like image space, by exploring opportunities like podcasts and businesses. This strengthens relationships with the community, promotes growth, and adds value.
🎆 Social Carousel: Do's/Don'ts
Slide 1:
"10 Social Commerce Insights from Meghana Dhar"
Slide 2:
"Community Support"
Cater to the needs of your community before focusing on marketplace dynamics.
Slide 3:
"Empower Creators"
Opportunities exist in enabling and monetizing creators beyond visual content.
Slide 4:
"Explore Social Commerce"
Capture the potential of social commerce and creator companies, as seen with TikTok shops.
Slide 5:
"Engage User Needs"
Align new features, like shopping, with user expectations to avoid friction.
Slide 6:
"Monitor Supply"
Apply stringent creator vetting for high-quality product supply, like Whatnot does.
Slide 7:
"Strive for Authenticity"
Work on building an authentic presence for engaging users, as Threads attempts.
Slide 8:
"Understand Platform Specifics"
Insta's need for user credit card information may deter first-time shoppers.
Slide 9:
"Respect Supply Base"
Reevaluate treating suppliers as interchangeable and strive to retain them.
Slide 10:
"Adapt to Changes"
Take a page from Snap's book and develop monetization strategies beyond ads.
Slide 11:
"Respect The Originals"
Remember pioneers like eBay's initial flywheel strategy to inspire innovation.
💼 LinkedIN - 6 Reasons Post
Ignoring social commerce is like throwing money out the window. As Meghana Dhar reveals, overlooking the power of social platforms for commerce is a critical misstep for brands aiming to thrive in the digital age. Let's unpack the key reasons why this oversight is costly:
Trust-building is vital for conversions.
Meghana emphasizes that platforms like TikTok are breeding grounds for creating trust between creators and their communities. This trust is a prelude to purchase, and neglecting the role of social commerce means missing out on the chance to convert this trust into sales.Social platforms evolve with consumer behavior.
Meghana notes Instagram could have capitalized more on social commerce. As consumer behavior shifts toward online shopping, brands that fail to follow this trend risk becoming irrelevant.Niche markets are untapped goldmines.
Whatnot’s success in niche communities showcases the importance of recognizing underserved markets. Ignoring specific, passionate communities can result in missed opportunities for unique product offerings and dedicated customer bases.Creator support equals platform loyalty.
eBay's growth was partly due to its investment in the seller community, as Meghana draws upon her experience. Social platforms that don't support their creators may drive them - and their followers - to more accommodating ecosystems.Ad changes mandate new strategies.
With the shakeup from iOS 14, as Meghana observes, platforms like Snap struggle with ad revenue and must innovate. Companies that don't adjust to new advertising landscapes are likely to fall behind.Shopping needs to align with user intent.
Meghana agrees with Ramon that adding e-commerce to platforms like Instagram has its downsides. User experience can suffer if the platform's core purpose is diluted by forced shopping features.
TL;DR:
Harness social commerce or lose out on trust-based revenue.
Evolving with consumer trends is non-negotiable.
Specialized markets offer lucrative opportunities.
Cultivate creator relationships to secure platform loyalty.
Adapt advertising strategies to meet changing regulations.
Ensure platform updates stay true to user intent.
Interview Breakdown
Join us as Meghana Dhar sheds light on her dynamic journey from the structured world of big tech to the innovative frontier of startups. With her finger on the pulse of social commerce and creator monetization, Meghana taps into the potential of emerging platforms and the shifting sands of online communities.
Today, she'll cover:
How her experiences at Snap and Instagram informed her views on supporting creator communities effectively.
The inevitable reckoning for current platforms and the exciting opportunities in social commerce beyond just images.
Insights into TikTok's approach to shopping, the pitfalls other platforms face, and her cautious optimism for its strategy.
The growing trend of following creators across different mediums, including podcasts, and its impact on traditional social networking.
The authentic engagement strategies of platforms like Whatnot versus the transactional nature of Instagram's shopping features.
🎠 Social Carousel
Cover Slide
"10 Must-Know Insights for Social Commerce Creators"
Slide 1: Startup Leap
"Embrace risk, venture from comfort zones to innovate within the startup landscape."
Slide 2: Community Support
"Platforms need to foster genuine community ties to stay relevant and grow."
Slide 3: Social Potential
"Dive into social commerce and creator companies—they're reshaping business."
Slide 4: Beyond Images
"Explore monetization in diverse areas like podcasts, creating businesses, and merchandise."
Slide 5: Instagram's Lesson
"Instagram could enhance its role as a key player in social commerce through incremental growth."
Slide 6: TikTok Strategy
"Utilize TikTok shops to leverage trust, but stay aware of potential over-commercialization pitfalls."
Slide 7: Creator Trust
"Support your favorite brands and creators directly on their websites to maintain trust."
Slide 8: Platform Transition
"People follow creators, not platforms. Be ready to switch and engage audiences elsewhere."
Slide 9: Shopping Friction
"Integrating shopping on Instagram poses trust and user experience challenges; tread carefully."
Slide 10: Embrace eBay's Model
"eBay's focus on creator care and community connection is instructive; learn from their strategy."
Final Slide: Join the Conversation
"Is your brand ready for the social commerce evolution? Share your thoughts with us at #DTCPod."
CTA: "Subscribe & Engage with DTC POD"
One Off Tweets
Tweet 1:
Jumping from big tech to startups isn't risky, it's strategic. Disruption starts where comfort zones end. Embrace change, embrace growth.
Tweet 2:
The social commerce wave is cresting but hasn't broken yet. Those who ride it with a focus on authentic community engagement will own the future.
Tweet 3:
Creators are the new entrepreneurs. Beyond images and likes, they're shaping businesses and economies with raw, unfiltered innovation.
Tweet 4:
Think social networks are static? Think again. The ebb and flow of platforms is a dance of creativity, with each new step an opportunity for connection.
Tweet 5:
Navigating TikTok's commercial labyrinth takes more than content—it’s about translating trust into transactions. Watch for those who do it right.
Tweet 6:
Beware the allure of shortcuts in social commerce. Easy doesn't always mean effective. The long game is about building lasting relationships with your audience.
Tweet 7:
Threads might just be the quiet underdog of social networks, bringing back the joy in just scrolling through thoughts and textual tapestries.
Tweet 8:
Remember eBay? It was the original marketplace gladiator. True power lies in nurturing a community that thrives on both giving and getting value.
Tweet 9:
When ads overshadow genuine content, platforms lose soul. Commerce should complement, not compromise, the user experience.
Tweet 10:
iOS 14 shook the ad industry, but it’s not just a challenge—it's a call to innovate. The future belongs to those who pivot with purpose.
Twitter Post 1
Meghana discovered that tapping into niche communities can do wonders for engagement. Just like on Whatnot, diving into the world of Pokemon collectibles and live card unboxings creates a vibrant, participatory marketplace culture.
Mindsets
As we navigate the ever-evolving landscape of social commerce and content creation, consider adopting these mindset shifts to leverage changing opportunities—the way Meghana Dhar discussed on DTC POD:
💭 Shift your perspective from passive consumption to active engagement. In the world of creator companies and social commerce, being a passive bystander isn’t enough. Engage with brands and creators by not just consuming their content but participating in their communities, providing feedback, and even collaborating. Your involvement can help shape the future of the platforms you love.
💭 Embrace the iterative approach to innovation. Like the cautious optimism Meghana shows towards TikTok's foray into shopping, it's crucial to understand that not all rollouts will be perfect from the start. By adopting this patient, iterative mindset, you can better appreciate the process of improvement and contribute to the development of these novel experiences.
💭 Prioritize authentic connection over convenience. As Meghana points out, platforms like Instagram and Whatnot are exploring different avenues to engage users. Understand that true community isn't built overnight through high-tech features—it's cultivated through consistent, genuine interactions. Whether you're a creator or consumer, choose platforms that resonate with your values and allow for meaningful connections, even if they might not be the most prominent or convenient.
To delve deeper into these insights and how they can apply to your journey with social commerce and beyond, tune in to Meghana Dhar's episode on DTC POD hosted by Blaine Bolus and Ramon Berrios. Their conversations might just spark the next big shift in your approach to digital spaces and creator engagement. 🎙️✨
Tactics
Ready to dial-up your business approach and give your strategy a dose of innovation? Meghana Dhar, previous Global Head of Partnerships at Snap and former Head of Partnerships for Instagram Shopping, shared some stellar insights on the latest DTC Pod episode. Here are five non-obvious tactics and strategies distilled from the conversation that can push your business forward:
🛒 Embrace Community-Driven Commerce: Take a page out of Whatnot’s playbook and focus on niche, engaged communities. Whether it's Pokémon collectibles or rare sneakers, encouraging live interactions like unboxings can spur excitement and drive sales. Create a space for your customers to connect and share passions, fostering loyalty and repeat engagement.
🚀 Be Intentional with Supply Dynamics: Instead of treating your suppliers as replaceable, cultivate them. eBay understood the power of a tight-knit seller community. Your suppliers can be advocates for your brand. Implement exhaustive vetting, incentivize sellers, and listen to their feedback. This approach can differentiate your platform from competitors and ensure a consistent, quality supply.
🎯 Enhance Customer Connection Without Growth Hacking: Rather than relying on short-term growth hacking strategies, build genuine connections. Tools like threads can offer a more satisfying, scrollable experience for text-based communities. Engage users authentically; a frictionless onboarding process should not substitute real value and community trust.
🛍️ Align Product Offerings with Customer Needs: Be cautious of feature overload — ask if shopping capabilities on platforms like Instagram align with what users "hire" the platform to do. As Meghana suggests, consider the jobs-to-be-done framework to ensure every addition to your platform or service fills a direct need for your user, avoiding confusion and maintaining platform integrity.
🧮 Navigate Post-iOS 14 Advertising with Creativity: With ad dynamics shifting and data privacy taking center stage, explore alternate revenue channels. Use Snap’s pivot towards AR shopping as inspiration to keep users engaged and advertisers interested. Diversify your monetization strategies to buffer against market changes that can potentially disrupt your main revenue streams.
Each of these strategies offers a nuanced approach to improving your business from a different angle, taking the wisdom of industry experts and applying it in practical, innovative ways. Keep these tactics in your arsenal and you’ll be well-equipped to adapt and thrive in today’s dynamic marketplace. And don't forget to tune in to DTC Pod for more insights that can help you drive your business forward.
In Depth Thread
Overrated: Traditional E-commerce Strategies.
Many businesses believe their online storefront needs flashy features and complex algorithms to succeed.
Underrated: Community-Driven Commerce.
Here's the exact blueprint I followed to nurture a die-hard community that turned a new social commerce startup into a thriving hub.
The Personal Touch Rule
Just like in a local mom-and-pop shop, the personal touch matters. Establish:
Community Guidelines
Regular Engagement Activities
Exclusive Offers for Loyal Customers
Feedback & Co-Creation Opportunities
Highlight Success Stories and User Testimonials
Niche Market Breakdown
Avoid drowning in the sea of general e-commerce. Nail down your niche with:
The specific community you serve now
How your community's needs will evolve
Why they trust your platform
Your unique value proposition within this niche
Growth projections for the niche over the next decade
Community Creed
Your mission statement should be crystal clear. E.g.:
“Our platform: ‘Empowering creators to forge closer connections and craft their economic success through social commerce.’”
Own the Narrative
Forge and adopt terminology that resonates with your community.
For us, it’s “Creator Economy” and “Social Selling.”
Define these terms and shape how they're understood.
User Journey
Highlight the seamless transition from community engagement to checkout.
Simplify the process visibly.
Marketplace Manifesto
Lay out the terms of how creators and users interact on your marketplace.
No hidden conditions – clear, concise expectations make for a trustworthy environment.
Visual Validation
Charts and infographics showcasing community growth, user engagement rates, and real-world success stories.
Design legal disclaimers properly; they matter here too.
Cultural Champions
Introduce the faces behind the marketplace, the real people who foster the community spirit.
Credentials and charisma are your currency.
And for emerging platforms seeking a breakthrough...
Show Off the Ecosystem
Maybe you don’t have massive sales figures yet, but you have a close-knit community and a robust engagement system.
Show your potential by turning the spotlight on the community you’ve built and the processes that nurture it.
We talk about 3Cs:
• Community, culture, and commerce
• Connection, creation, and conversion
Bullet-point these like they're the non-negotiables of your business proposal.
New Idea
Idea #1: The Reckoning of Current Platforms
The conversation with Meghana Dhar brought to light the notion that many existing social platforms may face an upcoming reckoning due to inadequate support of their communities. This claim is substantiated by the following pieces of evidence from the dialogue:
The Shift in Content Creation Spaces: Dhar highlighted that despite big tech's dominance, newer spaces for creativity and commerce, particularly those supporting podcast creators and merchandising, are expanding rapidly. This indicates a gap in the market not currently filled by incumbent platforms, signaling a potential shift in creator allegiance.
The Discontent with Social Commerce Execution: Meghana expressed a critical view of Instagram's approach to social commerce, suggesting that they rushed for revenue and did not allow time for organic development. This critique suggests that users and creators might feel underserved by the platform's strategy, leaving room for competitors to arise.
The Interest in Diverse Social Networks: Dhar's growing interest in emerging social networks and her activity of following creators across platforms is evidence of a broader user trend. This behavior reflects a search for alternative platforms that provide a more supportive environment for interacting with content and communities, underscoring the idea that the current social media giants might need to re-evaluate their role in the creator economy to avoid a reckoning.
Made with Castmagic
Turn any recording into a page like this.
Upload audio or video — interviews, podcasts, sales calls, lectures. Get a transcript, summary, key takeaways, and social-ready clips in minutes.
Or learn more about Castmagic first.
Magic Chat
Try asking
Google
Apple